A Hollywood club owner says he spent $500,000 on acoustics to make his room "dead." A technical director down the road is fighting a 1922 banquet hall that rings so much that bands swear he's added reverb. A concert hall in downtown LA is praised because its reflections arrive in a deliberate sequence. If you're stuck with a harsh, boomy room and a small budget, those three stories look like contradictions. They aren't, and they map neatly onto the choice between absorption and diffusion.
The venue details below come from the MusicTech feature on the best-sounding venues in Los Angeles. That piece gives no acoustic measurements for these rooms, and nobody here measured them. The translation to home studios, rehearsal rooms and small venues is analysis, and it's labeled as opinion wherever no spec or test backs it.
Three rooms, three philosophies
Sound Nightclub: absorb almost everything. Owner Kobi Danan tells MusicTech he spent $500,000 "just on acoustics, so it will be dead. There's no reflection or reverberation." He calls the sound good rather than the "best," and says the PA lets two people talk on the dance floor at full volume without yelling.
That's a use-case choice. The music is amplified house and techno, the PA supplies everything, and room sound would only blur it (opinion).
Lodge Room: keep the wood, tame the worst of it. This former banquet hall dates to 1922. Technical Director Raul Recendez says soundcheck gets very loud and bands are confused because "everything is ricocheting." They tell him there's too much reverb when, he says, he has none on.
Because the building is historic, he can't tear out walls. He hangs sound diffusion curtains and attaches panels to the ceiling, and admits they look a little awkward next to the antique chandelier. The feature also describes an in-the-round album release where the PA gave a "gentle lift" and the old room supplied natural reverb.
Disney Hall: design the reflections. Motoo Komoda, president of Nagata Acoustics, says reflections "should be coming one after another, not all in time." In a dome shape they arrive at the same time, which he calls "not a good thing."
The feature says the hall's materials and layout let sound resonate naturally, so orchestras don't need mics. It also says the room's oblong shape shapes the wall reflections, and that the wood is Alaskan Yellow Cedar. Amplified shows still happen there. FOH mixer Fred Vogler says you have to be careful in such a precise room and bring in only what's needed.
When to deaden, when to diffuse, when to leave it alone
Danan treats the room as a blank slate for a PA. Recendez treats it as part of the instrument and corrects only its excesses. Disney Hall treats geometry as the treatment. None of these is the right answer for every room. Each follows what the room is for. See read about audient id mk3 range: which interface should you buy? for additional background.
What follows is opinion, an inference from these case studies and general acoustic practice, not a documented result.
- Mostly absorb when the source is a speaker or a close-miked instrument and you need a neutral space: mixing rooms, vocal booths, DJ rooms, electronic-music clubs.
- Go mixed, with diffusion, when real instruments matter and the room is lively but manageable: tracking rooms, many rehearsal spaces.
- Leave it mostly alone when the room's character is the point and the audience hears the musicians directly, as at the Lodge Room show above. Fix only what makes soundcheck unbearable.
Comparison table
The only sourced figure here is Sound's $500,000. Cost levels and tradeoffs are opinion.
| | Dead room (absorb-heavy) | Diffused live room | Designed reflections | |---|---|---|---| | Best for | Amplified music, mix rooms, vocal booths | Rehearsal rooms, tracking rooms, small venues with live instruments | New builds, large acoustic rooms | | Cost level | High for a venue (Sound's owner cites $500,000); low to moderate for a home room | Moderate; can be built up in stages | Highest, since it's decided at design stage | | Main tradeoff | Can feel lifeless for acoustic players; bass needs thick or deep treatment | Needs the right surface in the right spot; diffusion won't cure boom | Hard to retrofit; a few panels can't copy it | | Case study | Sound Nightclub | Lodge Room | Disney Hall |
Why a wooden room can still work, and what curtains and ceiling panels fix
Recendez ties the loudness at soundcheck to the room's wooden construction. In his account, bands hear sound coming back from everywhere and read it as reverb. His fix targets the worst of it instead of stripping the room.
My read, as opinion: hanging fabric and ceiling panels take some energy out of the bounce between hard surfaces while the wood still gives the room its tone.
One caveat. The feature calls them "diffusion curtains," but heavy fabric normally works as an absorber at mid and high frequencies. That's an inference from general acoustics, not something the article says. Check how any treatment is rated before you assume what it does.
In a small room, the ceiling is the surface people forget. It's often bare, parallel to a hard floor, and close to the stage or the kit. Treating it is cheap compared with rebuilding walls (opinion). For more on this, see full coverage of roli seaboard after administration: keep, sell or switch.
Reading spec sheets without getting fooled
This section covers documented manufacturer specs only. The MusicTech piece names no treatment products, so no product numbers appear here, and no hands-on tests were done for this article. Look for these on a datasheet:
- Absorption coefficients by frequency band. Reputable manufacturers publish a coefficient for each octave or third-octave band from a lab test such as ISO 354 or ASTM C423. Bass performance shows up here, not in a single headline number.
- NRC or SAA. These averages cover roughly the mid-range. A high NRC says little about low-frequency control.
- Thickness and mounting. Coefficients depend on how the panel was tested. Check whether it was mounted flat on a wall or spaced off it, because your install will differ.
- Scattering or diffusion coefficients. For diffusers, look for data measured to ISO 17497, and the frequency range where the product scatters. Well depth and pattern set that range.
- Fire rating and material. For venues and rehearsal rooms open to the public, this matters before performance does.
Treat any product that gives only a single NRC, no thickness, and no frequency chart as unverified. A coefficient slightly above 1.0 on a datasheet is a known quirk of lab measurement, not a sign the panel is magic.
Decision checklist by room type
This checklist is opinion, based on the case studies above and general practice.
Also read: suno bridge with ableton live 12: try the beta or wait?
Tracking room
- Close-miked or loud sources? Lean toward absorption around the source.
- Acoustic instruments that want air? Add diffusion at the back and keep some reflective surface.
- Listen before you buy. Clap in the room and listen for flutter between parallel walls.
Rehearsal space
- Soundcheck harsh or too loud? Start with ceiling and rear-wall absorption.
- Players can't hear each other? You may have over-treated. Back off.
- Budget tight? Treat in stages and listen after each step.
Small venue
- Is the PA the main source, as in club music? A deader room, Sound-style, helps the PA.
- Does the audience hear musicians directly, as in jazz or acoustic sets? Follow the Lodge Room: keep the character, control the harshness.
- Can't change the structure because it's historic or leased? Use curtains and removable ceiling panels, as Recendez does.
What treatment can't fix
Small-room treatment has limits (opinion). Thin foam does little for bass, so low-frequency problems usually need thick absorbers, bass traps, or a change in speaker and listener position.
A 1922 hall with a ceiling you can't alter will keep some of its character. The Lodge Room case shows the realistic goal is managing it, not erasing it.
A designed hall like Disney Hall gets its result from room shape and materials chosen with the architects. Komoda says the shape was discussed carefully with them. Panels can't copy that.
So who should choose what? If your room feeds amplified electronic music or serves as a mix space, go mostly absorption and budget for bass. If it hosts live bands or tracking sessions, mix absorption with diffusion and add treatment in stages. If it's old, loved and mostly acoustic, leave the character alone and fix only the loud, harsh spots.



